I love the colour - I really do - the kind of inky black that I only get with other eyeliners after going over the line multiple times. In general, it stays on amazingly, even if I tear a little here or there (a Superdrug review claims it stays on through a breakdown but I've nev... Read more

I love the colour - I really do - the kind of inky black that I only get with other eyeliners after going over the line multiple times. In general, it stays on amazingly, even if I tear a little here or there (a Superdrug review claims it stays on through a breakdown but I've never tried). I have two issues with this though. One, as mentioned is that it flakes. I originally thought it might've been my mascara, but independently applying both produced tiny black flecks for the eyeliner and none for the mascara. Granted, they're really tiny flakes so they may go unnoticed unless someone's right in your face but... it flakes. The other issue is more personal - is it just me or is painting your eyelashes inevitable when using a liquid liner? Every time I use this, my eyelashes inevitably get some of the liner, which can make them clump up sometimes. Show less