Rimmel Wonderwing Eye Liner Black

I needed a new eyeliner and was short of time so picked this up. To be honest I hadn't even realised that it was designed to give you perfect eyeliner wings. Purely as an eyeliner, it was very pigmented and durability wise, stayed on for quite a long time. It wasn't the best going on though. I didn't feel like it glided on easily and as another reviewer has said, it did not work well going over eyeshadow at all. I also had issues just taking the lid off, and I noticed another reviewer said the same thing! I literally had to use my teeth top take the lid off and often still do!? Weird. The actual nib is a strange shape and when I used it to a actually create wings, I didn't feel like the design on the tip actually helped to create them, therefore the outcome was just my usual rubbish looking wings! If you're naturally good at doing wings then this could be a good eyeliner for you. Overall, I found it to be a disappointing product but at least it wasn't too expensive. Won't be repurchasing.

This has made my life so much easier when it come to doing wings phew. I absolutely adore this product. I’ve struggled so much to the perfect winged eyeliner. One is always messed up and I’m sure I’m no the only one who struggles when it comes to this. I’ve alreasy recommended to a few people. Buying it again is a must!

I really struggled with this product cause I had two issues with it, I found it hard to get the product out of the pen and once it started to flow it literally blotched up my line and I ended up having a smokey eyeliner look. By the time I went to my other eye the pen dried up again. After few hours of application one of my eyes looked like I'd missed drawing it, as the product started to wear off. The biggest downside is that the tip of this pen is very sharp and I poked my eyes few times while drawing. Not worth getting poked at.👎

✨I bought this after seeing a review on Huda Beauty thinking it was going to be fantastic. What initially drew me to it was the wing stamp, as I thought this was going to save me time in the morning perfecting my wing. Sadly, the stamp does not draw any type of wing and just ends up looking like a splodgy mess. When lining my eyelid, the product did not draw right and is very scratchy - not good for a precise line. When trying to draw over my eyeshadow, the product did not dispense at all and I could not draw to save my life on my lid. Possible one of the worst liners on the market.

I purchased this because I was in desperate need of an eyeliner. Unfortunately it wasn't very pigmented and within a couple of hours it had faded even more. I didn't like the stamp, it didn't look right, not a clean edge at all. I think I am actually going to have to throw it away as I really have no use for it. I would of kept it if it was more opaque as an emergency eyeliner but it's not worth it, I would rather not wear any eyeliner.

I won this from GG and i was really excited to try it out. I have always struggled with eyeliner on my lid and failed miserably when i attepted to do a wing so this sounded hopeful. Unfortunately i find its really awkward to get a good wing on my left eye. I think it would have been easier to use if the tip was the other way around and then it would be so much easier to get a good wing. However i absolutely love the pigmentation and i was able to get a nice easy application across my lid. I really like the formula and for that reason ill buy it again I'll keep practicing Thanks so much GG

I won this as a GG prize and I was intrigued by it, unfortunately the stamp isn't as easy to use as you'd think.Your hand has to be at thr right angle which is fine for one eye but extremely difficult on the other side.However the actual eyeliner is very black , pigmented and easy to apply the line, just not the wing.Unsure if I'd buy again but it's worth a try as i suppose once you work out how to use the stamp properly it could be really handy for on the go

I won this on the GG competition and I have been wanting to try and eyeliner stamp for ages so was super excited. However, it is still not the easiest thing to master. You can't really see where you are aiming so getting each side even is hard. If you push down too hard you get s very thick and not very wing like shape so a light tap is best. The pigment is good and I could use it as a normal liner. I'm not sure I will ever master a good wing line though so if you are good at there already this may be worth a purchase. Not too good for a beginner like me.

I won this in the Glamgeek weekly review comp and was so excited to try it. I'm not great at eyeliner so thought this would help being a novice. The formula is thin and the colour is not very black. The wing stamp itself is OK if you line it up right but it does need perfecting. However doing this pulled off the liner and make up that was already there. It was like using a whiteboard marker on a whiteboard (I'm sure I even heard it 'squeak'). I would have given 1 star but have given 2 stars because maybe someone a bit more experienced might get on better with it.